Explained: Is Pakistan really about to create new provinces?

Ministers have floated the idea for months, but no draft amendment exists, and the constitutional hurdles are high.

Parliament House in Islamabad. Any new province needs two-thirds majorities in both houses. Photo: Mhtoori / CC BY-SA 4.0 via Wikimedia Commons

Talk of carving new provinces out of Pakistan's existing four has grown louder this autumn. Defence Minister Khawaja Asif recently suggested on television that several could arrive by the New Year, though he stressed it was his personal view. So how real is the plan?

Who is pushing it

Interior Minister Mohsin Naqvi first raised the idea publicly at an economic summit in Islamabad on 30 July. Planning Minister Ahsan Iqbal has spoken of 12 to 15 provinces created by consensus. Naqvi has since said the public should decide by referendum.

But as of this week there is no draft amendment, no agreed number of provinces and no timetable. Health Minister Mustafa Kamal of the MQM-P has said the cabinet has not formally discussed it.

The legal hurdles

The constitution names four provinces and sets out no separate process for creating more. The debate centres on Article 239. A constitutional amendment needs two-thirds of each house: 224 of 336 members of the National Assembly and 64 of 96 senators.

A change to a province's boundaries also needs a two-thirds vote in that province's own assembly, which would mean 248 of 371 members in Punjab, or 112 of 168 in Sindh. Lawyers say a referendum could not replace that process, and Pakistan's three past referendums were all held under military rulers.

Where the parties stand

  • PML-N has no formal position and says it will set one out if the matter reaches parliament.
  • PPP firmly opposes dividing Sindh. The Sindh Assembly rejected the idea in September.
  • MQM-P wants smaller administrative units, including provincial status for Karachi.

The costs

A study by the think tank PRIME estimated that splitting Punjab into three would cost about 47 to 56 billion rupees a year, before set-up costs. Turning all 30 divisions into provinces could cost more than 600 billion rupees a year. Unresolved questions include how to divide tax revenue and river water under the 1991 accord.

Senate elections in early 2027 may be the next point at which the idea is tested.

This report draws on reporting by Al Jazeera.

Comments

Please keep comments civil and on topic. We remove abuse, personal attacks, hate speech, spam and anything that may be unlawful.

Loading comments…